Something I watched recently made me want to write on a topic that I have no interest in and only passing experience with, but which is intriguing once you think about it for a moment. I decided I would blog about the first such thing I could come up with. After thinking for more than a few moments the first thing I came up with fitting this description was:
Barbicide. It’s that blue liquid that every barber/hair salon uses to store combs and scissors, presumably to disinfect it in some way. Before reading that Wikipedia article, some obvious questions about Barbicide come to mind:
- Is there really no competition for Barbicide? How do they maintain their monopoly? There doesn’t seem to be a monopoly on the combs or the scissors, just the blue liquid that cleans them.
- Why always blue? Presumably it is some kind of branding. Does Barbicide have a patent/copyright on that particular shade of blue?
- The name suggests that it is a special chemical agent for killing some kind of mythical organism whose name has the root Barbi-. But I don’t believe that. In fact, I believe that Barbicide is just de-natured alcohol colored blue. But I must be wrong right?
- How often do you have to change a jar of Barbicide?
The wikipedia article didn’t answer many of these questions but it did say something about 3. In fact barbicide
… is a United States Environmental Protection Agency-approved hospital disinfectant. It is a germicide, pseudomonacide, fungicide, and viricide. In addition, it kills the HIV-1 virus (AIDS virus), Hepatitis B, and Hepatitis C.
And it raised new questions. Like, is it true as “Barbicide techinicians claim” that
it is the only disinfectant of its kind which holds its power and color over time; all of its competitors’ products eventually turn green or brown.
? That at least tells me that there are indeed competitors and presumably they are all blue (at first.) I checked the Barbicide Material Safety Data Sheet, a document prepared by OSHA and confirmed that alcohol is the primary active ingredient, although it also contains Dimethyl Benzyl Ammonium Chloride (DBAC), and Sodium Nitrite. I checked the Wikipedia page for DBAC and found some uninteresting (to me) facts like that it is a
nitrogenous cationic surface-acting agent belonging to the quaternary ammonium group
and some interesting facts like that it is toxic to fish. Apparently it is not patented. So Barbicide must be a patented formula combining these chemicals in some specific proportions with other, presumably blue, chemicals.
I went to the homepage for Barbicide. Did you know that a jar of Barbicide is in the permanent collection at the National Museum of American History at the Smithsonian Institution? Now you do. King Research, which produces Barbicide also makes other products, for example a drain cleaner that apparently excels at breaking down hair clogs. Natch.
I found this discussion forum where exactly my question 4 was raised and after many forum members professed ignorance, a call was placed directly to King Research who suggest replacing it every day, or when it gets cloudy. This surprised me because when you factor in the claims of the Barbicide technicians, it seems to suggest that the competitor’s product turns brown or green in less than a day. Well, no wonder they can’t compete.
Finally, I assumed that somewhere there must be a dark side to all of this, so I googled “Against Barbicide” and “Barbicide Controversies” and after many such attempts I finally came across the following transcript of a case from the Third Circuit Court of Appeal in which Barbicide was allegedly improperly used to sanitize a tub used in a pedicure:
Ms. Detraz demonstrated that Virgin Nails did not follow proper sanitization procedures when cleaning its equipment, specifically the pedicure tub in which Ms. Detraz immersed her feet and lower legs during the pedicure. Virgin Nails used Barbicide, a disinfectant, to clean the whirlpool tubs attached to the pedicure chairs.
So, I learned a lot and it is not all for naught. I think that I might actually have an interesting topic of conversation the next time I get my haircut.
6 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 11, 2009 at 11:18 am
Paul
I think this is my favorite Cheap Talk post ever.
April 13, 2009 at 1:52 pm
Alex
Its interesting that you mention things like Barbicide having some sort of monopoly- its a fact that they did at one time have a virtual vice grip on the beauty profession because of a serious lack of competition against them. Oh, how times have changed! There are now smaller companies out there banging on their doors, Ameri-Kleen is one such company that has a “one-step” disinfectant that actually cleans and disinfects in one step, hooray for innovation!
NOT to mention that if you use Barbicide to properly disinfectant a spa chair, it takes 8 ounces of Barbicide for EVERY gallon of water (that’s the dilution rate to all you pencil pushers). So if you were wanting to disinfect a spa chair, and lets say a typical spa chair unit is 5 gallons, thats a whopping 40 ounces of Barbicide disinfectant to “disinfect” a single pedicure chair (yikes!, that’s 24 ounces shy of a gallon for you measurement fanatics). With a newer, time saving product like Ameri-Kleen, you would be using only 5 ounces of disinfectant, which does our environment a helluva more good than 40 ounces of bacteria killing soup-mix going down the drain. Plus, did I mention that it has surfactants in it to “clean” your stuff at the same time as killing the creepy-crawlies that lurk in its depths?
Barbicide was a staple at every corner barber shop for years. Times change, disinfectants get better and we are able to do more with less, move over Barbi, here comes Mr. Ameri-Kleen to the rescue!
April 15, 2009 at 7:28 pm
mad
“I found this discussion forum where exactly my question 4 was raised and after many forum members professed ignorance, a call was placed directly to King Research who suggest replacing it every day, or when it gets cloudy.”
I have no experience with Barbicide of course, but I’m not surprised that they would suggest a quick turnover of the fluid; got to keep the cash flow going! Rinse and repeat!
May 21, 2009 at 10:29 pm
The Epistemology of Wikipedia « Cheap Talk
[…] For example, Barbicide. […]
December 15, 2009 at 3:53 am
josianne
How often do you have to change a jar of Barbicide?
January 21, 2010 at 8:39 am
Arthur
A truly great blog, Jeff. It captures perfectly the spirit of unlimited intellectual resources chasing almost nothing. The term barbicide, if remember high school Latin, most naturally would mean something that kills beards, or barbers, for that matter, since the Latin for beard is something like barba. Along the lines of fungicide, something that kills fungi. Only its facial fungus now. It not clear why the makers of barbicide would have intended these meanings. Although beards are somehow often associated with evil. A nice word that captures a spirit of hostility to beards is rebarbative– repellent, etc.