There was a story on NPR about a program in Texas to decentralize border patrol efforts. Texas sheriffs are webcasting their surveillance cameras to the website bluservo.net where private citizens can login, monitor the video stream and report any suspicious activity they see.
Putting aside the political dimension of this, I see it as an interesting case study in open-source security. In the realm of computer network security, there is a debate about openness vs “security by obscurity.” For example, we may debate whether an open-source operating system like Linux is more or less secure than closed-source Windows. On the one hand, the security measures are in plain view for all the black-hats to see and try to circumvent. On the other hand, the openness enables the enourmous community of white hats to fix whatever problems they find. Which effect dominates?
The Texas sheriffs apparently side with the open-source community on this one. They seem not to be worried that the black-hat coyotes will use these cameras to figure out where to cross the border without being seen.

2 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 21, 2009 at 12:26 pm
Paul
I don’t know if there’s a real comparison here, though, because it’s not like the white-hats can fix the problems they can find. This is more just like the Texas people are crowdsourcing to lighten their loads. It may be that since they didn’t have the manpower to watch all these cameras, most of them would go unwatched anyway, so it doesn’t matter if the coyotes know where they are because a camera you can’t watch might as well not exist. If they are able to crowdsource those areas out, they reduce the amount of border that they have to watch.
April 21, 2009 at 2:15 pm
James Moore
I’m with Paul – it’s crowdsourcing, not open source.
The key concept in open source is forking. If you can’t fork, it’s not open source. If the sheriffs retain control over the cameras, it’s not open source.
If anyone can go in and replace/move/alter the cameras themselves, then we’re talking open source. Until then, it’s a very different beast.