If Indian capitalism has left you behind, your remaining options are begging or a scam to rip off tourists. A British journalist encountered this scam:
“I was emerging from an underpass in Connaught Place when a shoeshine man came up to me, and whispered into my ear the word “shit”. He then pointed at my right shoe on which sat, to my amazement, a small slug of brownish goo. He offered to wipe it off, in return for 100 rupees – but I suspected something was, well, afoot, and I cleaned it with a few leaves. Some months later it happened again and I had a minor altercation with the shoeshine man. One day, I decided I’d photograph the person who had squirted my shoe. But I was daydreaming as I wandered through the underpass – and was squirted again. This time, I’m embarrassed to say, I became incandescent with rage. To the consternation of passers by, and to my everlasting shame, I grabbed the man and rubbed the filth off my shoe on to his trousers.”
It seems more original than the “Come into my carpet shop – I give you good price” scam but it has a rich history:
“I also heard about older versions of the scam, in Cairo during the Second World War, and most unexpectedly in a book published in 1948, The Otterbury Incident by Cecil Day-Lewis. There is one scene in which boys hidden in a cellar use flit guns to spray the shoes of passers-by with muddy water. Two other boys are waiting a little way off, next to a sign reading “SHOE-SHINE – 3d”. Flit guns were a household device for spraying insecticide – and they’re still used in India.”
FYI: A Flit gun is a hand-pumped insecticide sprayer used to dispense Flit, a brand-name insecticide widely used against flies and mosquitoes between 1928 and the mid-1950s. Although named after the well-known brand, “Flit gun” became a generic name for this type of dispenser.
5 comments
Comments feed for this article
July 20, 2010 at 10:23 am
Hari
This isn’t solely an oriental phenomenon:
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/toronto/story/2010/05/28/toronto-theives-feces.html
July 20, 2010 at 6:47 pm
sandeep
Thanks for this great link.
July 20, 2010 at 11:19 pm
anon
Here’s a relatively common occurrence in Manhattan. Someone bumps into you while walking on the street and intentionally drops a pair of broken glasses. Then blames you for breaking the pair of glasses and demands you to compensate him.
I’m surprised that this works at all, but I personally know of at least one instance where someone was in such a hurry and paid ~$100, not immediately realizing it was a scam. Anecdotally it seems like they target business folks as opposed to tourists etc.
July 21, 2010 at 3:13 am
EJ
This happens is Shanghai as well, on the sidewalks near the posh shopping area of Xintiandi. But instead of s**t, they use a white cream or paste that looks more like bird poop, but could just as well be actual shoe shine cream. If you’re watching closely, you’ll see the little squeeze bottle quickly pocketed or dropped in their case.
The interesting thing is, if the scammer bend to wipe your shoe, and then you argue, the local security guards will support the scammer and insist that you pay his asking price. If you make a scene before the trickster renders any service though, the guards will chase him away and apologize.
The unfortunate, although maybe essential, thing is that there are legitimate, if not particularly high-quality, shoe shiners wandering the same district, with the same general kit as the scammers. They now just get scowls from anyone in the know, since we can’t tell who’s a scammer and who’s not.
July 25, 2010 at 5:01 pm
Dan
Happened to me in New Orleans — except that it was soap-paste. Same idea — you want them to get the paste off the shoe.