I remember once thinking what an amazing stroke of luck it was that on the Earth there happen to be so many wonderful gifts for people to enjoy. For example, it seemed close to definitive proof of a benevolent God that tangerines were just hanging there from trees for us to pick and eat. Somebody had to understand us very well and care about us a lot to give us this delicacy for free.
Of course this is a fallacy. It was not the fruit that was designed for our taste buds but the other way around.
We need to be incentivized to consume whatever we need to survive. And there is no need to bring any Designer into the story because this can be taken care of by natural selection.
These points are nicely recounted in this TED lecture by Dan Dennett. However, he stops short of considering the plot twist in which we develop conscious thought and learn how to manipulate nature’s incentive scheme. It starts with nutra-sweet, vasectomies and pornography. That’s when the real game begins.

2 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 22, 2009 at 12:19 pm
Paul
Don’t forget that it’s not just us evolving to like tangerines. We are an agricultural society and as such we’ve been selecting for the best and most delicious foods and treats for thousands of years. My understanding is that every commercial banana tree (the kind of banana you get in the US) is a clone (meaning they are all identical). We didn’t just evolve to like the foods we have, we made them evolve to be likeable foods.
June 25, 2009 at 10:26 pm
Emotions as an Incentive Mechanism « Cheap Talk
[…] tricks nature has concocted to get us to do her bidding. I am on record in this blog as being a fan of this methodology. But I also maintain a healthy skepticism and not just at the tendency to […]